Todt Hill, Staten Island

Todt Hill, Staten Island: Explore a Unique Community

Todt Hill, located in Staten Island, is one of the most exclusive neighborhoods in New York City. It holds the distinction of being the highest natural point in the city, offering panoramic views of the surrounding areas.

The neighborhood is known for its luxurious homes, serene environment, and lack of commercial development, reinforcing its primarily residential character. Todt Hill has a rich history dating back to its Dutch colonial roots, and the origin of its name is a point of interest for many.

The community offers a suburban lifestyle with privacy and safety, attracting affluent residents. Notable public figures and celebrities have called Todt Hill home, adding to its allure and prestige.

While the neighborhood boasts natural beauty and exclusive amenities, it also presents challenges such as limited access to public transportation and commercial conveniences.

Todt Hill’s unique combination of location, history, architecture, and community makes it a desirable and intriguing place to explore for both potential residents and curious visitors.

Geographic and Natural Features of Todt Hill

The geographic and natural features of Todt Hill play a significant role in its appeal. With an elevation of 410 feet (125 meters), it is the highest natural point in New York City. This altitude provides residents with stunning panoramic views of the surrounding areas, including the New York City skyline, the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge, and the Atlantic Ocean.

The neighborhood is also known for its natural beauty and serene environment. Lush greenery, mature trees, and well-manicured lawns create a peaceful atmosphere that feels far removed from the hustle and bustle of city life.

Todt Hill is home to several parks and green spaces, offering residents opportunities for outdoor recreation and leisure. One notable park is Deere Park, a large wooded area that features a Korean War memorial and the Staten Island Greenbelt Blue Trail. The nearby High Rock Park also offers hiking trails for outdoor enthusiasts. Additionally, Valentino Vista and Jerome X. O’Donovan ponds are located in the area, providing scenic spots for residents to enjoy and engage in fishing activities.

The combination of elevation, natural beauty, and recreational spaces contributes to the unique character and appeal of Todt Hill, setting it apart from other neighborhoods in Staten Island.

Affluence and Residential Character

Todt Hill is known for its affluent and residential character, with a predominance of luxurious homes and properties. The neighborhood features a diverse range of architectural styles, including grand Colonial, Tudor, and Mediterranean-style homes.

Many of these houses are situated on large, well-manicured lots, providing residents with ample privacy and space. The properties often boast high-end finishes, spacious interiors, and upscale amenities, reflecting the tastes and means of the affluent residents who call Todt Hill home.

One of the defining characteristics of Todt Hill is the absence of significant commercial development. The neighborhood is primarily residential, with few businesses or retail establishments within its boundaries. This lack of commercial activity contributes to the peaceful, suburban atmosphere that residents value.

The combination of luxurious homes, expansive properties, and limited commercial development creates an exclusive and upscale environment that sets Todt Hill apart as one of the most prestigious neighborhoods in Staten Island.

Historical Background

Todt Hill has a notable history dating back to the Dutch colonial era when it was part of New Netherland, established in the early 17th century.

The name “Todt Hill” comes from the Dutch word “dood,” meaning “dead,” possibly due to an early burial ground set up by Dutch settlers. The area was once called “Yserberg,” which is Dutch for “Iron Hill,” reflecting its iron mining history, with activities recorded as early as 1644 and extensive mining between 1832 and 1881.

Todt Hill has housed various notable residents, including members of the Vanderbilt family who owned a large estate there in the late 19th century. During the Revolutionary War, its high elevation made it a strategic lookout point for British forces. The area also had one of the first tuberculosis sanatoriums in the United States in the 19th century.

In 1895, Hudson River School painter Jasper Cropsey created the painting “Looking Oceanward from Todt Hill,” capturing views of New Dorp, Raritan Bay, and the New Jersey Highlands​​. The St. Francis Friary, built in 1928, adds to the area’s history, with its surrounding woodlands preserved as part of the Staten Island Greenbelt​​.

Today, Todt Hill’s history is reflected in its architecture, with many homes from the early 20th century. This historical background contributes to the neighborhood’s distinct character and interest for those studying Staten Island’s development and heritage.

Community and Lifestyle

Todt Hill offers residents a unique lifestyle that combines the tranquility of a suburban setting with the benefits of living within New York City. The neighborhood is known for its strong sense of community, with many residents actively involved in local organizations and events.

The Todt Hill Civic Association plays a significant role in fostering this community spirit, organizing various activities and initiatives throughout the year. These include annual picnics, holiday celebrations, and community cleanup efforts, which bring residents together and promote a sense of belonging.

Despite its exclusive nature, Todt Hill is home to several local landmarks and institutions that serve the community. The Richmond County Country Club, founded in 1888, is a historic golf course and social club that has long been a gathering place for the neighborhood’s elite.

The St. Charles Seminary, a Roman Catholic institution, is another notable presence in Todt Hill. The seminary, which dates back to the late 19th century, has played a significant role in the religious life of the community and has trained many prominent clergy members over the years.

The combination of a strong sense of community, historic institutions, and a peaceful suburban atmosphere makes Todt Hill an attractive place to live. For those seeking a balance between the excitement of city life and the tranquility of a more rural setting.

Education and Transportation

Education is a key consideration for families living in Todt Hill, and the neighborhood offers a range of options for students of all ages. The New York City Department of Education serves the area, with several public schools located in and around the neighborhood.

One notable institution is P.S. 11 Thomas Dongan School, an elementary school that serves students from kindergarten through fifth grade. The school has a strong academic reputation and offers a variety of enrichment programs, including music, art, and technology classes.

For older students, Todt Hill is home to the prestigious Staten Island Academy, a private, co-educational school that serves students from pre-kindergarten through 12th grade. The academy boasts a rigorous academic curriculum, small class sizes, and a wide range of extracurricular activities.

In terms of transportation, Todt Hill is primarily served by buses operated by the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA). The S74 and S84 bus routes connect the neighborhood to other parts of Staten Island, including the Staten Island Ferry terminal, which provides access to Manhattan.

For those who prefer to drive, Todt Hill is conveniently located near several major roadways, including the Staten Island Expressway (I-278) and the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge, which connects Staten Island to Brooklyn. However, traffic congestion during peak hours can be a concern for commuters.

While the transportation options in Todt Hill may be more limited compared to other parts of New York City, residents have found ways to adapt and make the most of the available resources. Carpooling, ride-sharing, and careful planning of daily routes can help mitigate some of the challenges associated with commuting from this exclusive enclave.

Notable Residents

Over the years, Todt Hill has been home to several notable residents who have contributed to the neighborhood’s reputation and character. One of the most well-known figures associated with Todt Hill is Paul Castellano, the former head of the Gambino crime family. Castellano lived in a large mansion on Benedict Road, which was a symbol of his wealth and influence in the 1970s and early 1980s.

Another resident of Todt Hill was Frank Cali, who was believed to be the acting boss of the Gambino crime family until he died in 2019. Cali’s presence in the neighborhood highlighted the historical connections between Todt Hill and organized crime.

Todt Hill has also been home to several successful business leaders and philanthropists. Robert Mazzuoccola, the founder of Tropical Shipping, one of the largest transportation companies in the Caribbean, lived in the neighborhood for many years.

Richard Nicotra, a well-known real estate developer and the owner of the Hilton Garden Inn and Hampton Inn & Suites in Staten Island, also lives in Todt Hill. Nicotra and his wife, Lois, are known for their charitable work and support of various educational and community organizations in the borough.

Todt Hill has also appeared in popular culture. Parts of the movie “Angel Heart” (1987), which starred Robert De Niro, were filmed in the neighborhood. The home of De Niro’s character, Dr. Fowler, was said to be located at 419 Kitteredge in Todt Hill. However, it’s important to note that 419 Kitteredge is a made-up address created for the movie and does not exist in real life. Still, the connection to a major film adds another interesting layer to the neighborhood’s history.

The presence of these notable residents, from criminals to business leaders and even a fictional movie character, has helped shape the unique character and reputation of Todt Hill. While some may focus on the neighborhood’s ties to organized crime, others celebrate the success and generosity of its more upstanding residents, as well as its brief appearance in a Hollywood film.

Challenges and Considerations

While Todt Hill offers a desirable lifestyle, it is important to consider the practical challenges that come with living in such an exclusive neighborhood. One of the primary concerns is transportation, as the area is not well-served by public transit options.

Due to the limited bus routes and absence of a nearby train station, most residents rely on private vehicles for their daily commutes and errands. This dependence on cars can be inconvenient for those who prefer public transportation or wish to reduce their carbon footprint.

Another consideration is the limited access to commercial amenities within the neighborhood itself. While the lack of businesses contributes to the peaceful atmosphere, it also means that residents must travel outside of Todt Hill for most of their shopping, dining, and entertainment needs.

Nearby neighborhoods such as Dongan Hills and Richmondtown offer more diverse options for retail and services. However, the need to travel for these conveniences may be a drawback for some potential residents.

Despite these challenges, many residents find that the benefits of living in Todt Hill, such as the stunning views, spacious properties, and strong sense of community, outweigh the inconveniences posed by limited transportation and commercial options.


In conclusion, Todt Hill stands as one of Staten Island’s most remarkable and exclusive neighborhoods, offering a unique blend of natural beauty, historical significance, and luxurious living. From its perch atop the highest natural point in New York City, Todt Hill provides residents with stunning views and a tranquil, suburban atmosphere that feels far removed from the hustle and bustle of urban life.

The neighborhood’s rich history, which spans centuries and includes ties to notable figures and events, adds depth and character to the community. The luxurious homes and well-manicured properties that define Todt Hill create an air of prestige and exclusivity that attracts affluent residents seeking privacy and comfort.

Despite the challenges posed by limited public transportation and commercial options, Todt Hill’s strong sense of community, excellent educational opportunities, and convenient location near major roadways make it an appealing choice for those who value a balance between urban amenities and suburban tranquility.

While the neighborhood’s past may be marked by associations with infamous criminals, Todt Hill’s present and future are shaped by the many successful and philanthropic individuals who call it home. These residents, along with the natural splendor and architectural beauty of the area, contribute to the enduring allure of this one-of-a-kind enclave.

For those seeking an extraordinary living experience within the diverse tapestry of New York City, Todt Hill offers a compelling combination of history, luxury, and community that is truly unmatched.

Spread the Staten Island Spirit

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *